Sunday, May 2, 2010

Race and Contemporary Hollywood Part 01


Okay, this post was prompted by this film: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ys-bUD_Uj4

First and foremost let's address this troubling film. As I'm sure you all have noticed, the film is titled the Prince of Persia, which is based on a video-game franchise of the same title. Now barring the fact that the game franchise was from its outset developed by white American developers, lets examine the real problem here. Jake Gyllenfuckinhaal, while a phenomenal actor in his own right, is a white fuckin' male! I don't care how one may try to spin it, there's no way around that.

So, while Persians may be part of the "caucasoid race", actual Persians (i.e.-Iranians/those people that Washington and the rest of the West seem to want to bomb to Hell) and I would be inclined to disagree with them being considered white enough to be portrayed in film by a Swedish/Jewish male. I'm sorry, it just doesn't fly Hollywood. Seriously, there are so many great Iranian actors and the best you could do was Gyllenhaal? Seriously? Please tell me you're kidding, because if your excuse is that the audience needs someone they can relate to, I can tell you that between 40 and 30% of Americans aren't going to be able to relate to Gyllenhaal (myself being part of that number).

Then there is the problem of the female lead and, boy oh boy, is it a problem. Gemma Arterton is English. That's right, she's straight up from the land of Fish 'n Chips. Now, I know what you're thinking, especially if you didn't click on the link, "Well what's wrong with that Vagrant?" I'll tell you in two words. Ethnic Face. Yes, Ethnic Face. While in the past we limited this title to depictions of African Americans (i.e.-black face) I'm sure we can all acknowledge that every race and ethnicity has been portrayed by a white man in cinema. One infamous example being Charlie Chan (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Chan). Gemma Arterton continues this "proud" tradition of Ethnic Face, though not quite as blatantly, by taking up the role of Tamina who is, quite obviously, some subset of the "ethnic princess/ethnic concubine/ethnic minx/ethnic whatever other stereotypical female role you can think of". Seriously, two for two already? I don't even want to know what the rest of this "diverse" cast looks like (but I can guess you've got at least one POC who will end up dying 20 minutes into the film. Sarcastic YAY!"

But then again, knowing that it is going to be produced by Walt Disney demystifies the whole situation. After all, these are the people who brought you that gem of a film titled The Princess and the Frog (Proceeds to vomit profusely into a bucket). And this brings me to my next point. Hollywood is seriously laying on the stereotypes mighty thick even in the 21st century and this is a major problem. All one needs to do is look at a Queen Latifah movie, an Ice Cube movie, etc. And that's to say nothing of the roles that men and women of colour are pigeon holed into, especially women of colour. I doubt you'll see Bai Ling ethnic facing a white russian bride in searching for her white husband, played by John Cho, who presumably died fighting the Nazis though she refuses to believe that.

Seriously, this reminds me of a Paul Mooney skit that appeared on Dave Chappelle: http://www.comedycentral.com/videos/index.jhtml?videoId=219442

Anyway, that's all I've got for now. Part 02 of this rant will be up a little later.

7 comments:

  1. Oh yes! When I said it was weird that The Prince of 'Persia' was actually a white dude I was told I see race in everything and that The Prince of Persia is an American game and the movie is American so they can do whatever they like. Sure they can do whatever they like. Doesn't mean it's not racist. Even in the game he doesn't look remotely white! Couldn't they at least get someone who looked Middle Eastern?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Disney movies are rich with stereotyping and blatant racism. Not to be missed: Aladdin (note the variance of the accents), The Jungle Book (jive-talkin' monkeys...nice... also note the accents of other characters), Song of the South.... *sigh* no words. Peter Pan (a song about Native Americans referring to them as "red" men and contemplating the reason for such a skin tone). The Disney channel sucks hardcore as well. I recently emailed them (and Nickelodeon) on it, actually. Of course, no one has responded. Big surprise there. Just YouTube or Google racism in Disney movies if you ever need to vomit.

    Do these companies not realize that they could make so much money by reversing the very stereotypes they have created and/or maintained? Really - what would have happened if Castaway had been about a black man stranded on an island, risking his life to get back to his woman and civilization? Oh,that's right, corporate d-bags actually believe most of the stereotypes they maintain, and think that showing a black man in love would be inaccurate to (their) reality.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The funny thing... Gyllenhaal is Jewish (right?), and Jews are Semites. Persians were Indo Europeans. So it's another way thing they got wrong.

    Even though I see Iranians as white, I hate when they do this "race update" thing to appeal the audience. First of all, all they manage is to piss audience off. Second of all, it's not just racist, it's offensive in so many ways, it feeds people's stereotypes and it's unrealistic.

    I doubt you'll see Bai Ling ethnic facing a white russian bride in searching for her white husband, played by John Cho, who presumably died fighting the Nazis though she refuses to believe that.

    Actually, that would be interesting to see...

    Nice blog, btw. I'm bookmarking it and I can't wait for part II.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Lady X: Believe me, I've been asking that same question since I found out about the casting decisions. *Shakes head wearily*

    @vintagelux: The day Hollywood (e.g.-Movie producers) learn that is the day I have one less thing to rage about. However, though you might already know this, Walt Disney was not exactly singing It's a Small World After All. He was known as quite the staunch racist, so I'm not really surprised that Disney, the company, has produced the racist depictions and songs it has.

    @Mira: Thanks for dropping by, and thank you!

    The funny thing... Gyllenhaal is Jewish (right?), and Jews are Semites. Persians were Indo Europeans. So it's another way thing they got wrong.

    Don't even get me started on this one...

    Even though I see Iranians as white, I hate when they do this "race update" thing to appeal the audience. First of all, all they manage is to piss audience off. Second of all, it's not just racist, it's offensive in so many ways, it feeds people's stereotypes and it's unrealistic.

    Never doubt the vanity of the White American movie goer. This movie, despite having a paper thin plot and overall mediocre acting, actually grossed quite a bit on its opening day I believe. Also, I agree wholeheartedly with your second point. Unfortunately it doesn't seem as though they're going to change anytime soon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is discouraging to see "Prince of Persia" is doing well at the box office, but I hope the same won't happen with "The Last Airbender". Still, this kind of movies usually get bad reviews and are not that popular among fans of the games/animated shows. There are many colour blind white racists, but even they would prefer to see non-white actors in these roles. By casting white actors producers alienate most of the fanbase, even the white people. So they lose money. If they don't care about accuracy and people who are not white, shouldn't they care about money at least?

    On the other hand, "Avatar", the ultimate white fantasy was so popular so I guess I'm wrong here.

    ReplyDelete
  6. So not only did the Prince manage to defy the future, he also managed to defy common sense and racial sensitivity? Color me surprised... (Sarcasm)

    It's stuff like this that makes me weep for the future of humanity, especially white Americans/those who support the current racial hierarchy.

    And, yes, they do. The problem lies in the fact that enough people go to see these terrible movies, and, often offset the production cost at the very least. Take the Transformers movies for instance; horrible acting, writing, and replete with stereotypes. However, the populous sure does love those digital explosions!

    *Shakes head and sighs*

    ReplyDelete